Probation: The nicest sounding way to grease the skids of mass incarceration

by Peter Wagner, August 11, 2015  

Last week, Shaila Dewan had a brilliant story in the New York Times about how probation sentences set people up to fail: Probation May Sound Light, but Punishments Can Land Hard. The article follows a woman who was arrested for drunk driving, her first offense of any kind, and whose life entered a very expensive spiral, including the loss of two jobs and having to pay almost $4,000 in fees, fines, and court costs and $2,000 to post bail. In addition, she was forced to spend 34 days in the dirty, dank, dangerous and disgraceful Baltimore jail simply because she was unable to find attendance slips from her required A.A. meetings, and she could not afford another $2,500 bail bond to get out of jail time.

Because many people on probation fail to meet the conditions of their community supervision, probation often isn’t the alternative to incarceration it’s made out to be. The harm of probation would be important even if probation were rare; but more than half the people under correctional control are on probation.

Graph showing that for the last 40 years more people have been on probation than in prison or on parole.Since the beginning of the statistics almost 40 years ago, the probation population has grown much more quickly than either the number of people on parole or the number of people in federal, state and local prisons and jails. While about 2.3 million U.S. residents were behind bars in 2012, almost 4 million residents were under probation.

Like imprisonment, there is tremendous variation between the states on the use of probation, but these differences aren’t parallel. For example, Rhode Island has the 48th highest incarceration rate, but the third highest rate of probation.

As the Council of State Governments’ Justice Center has shown, Rhode Island’s probation sentences are 53% longer than the U.S. average, and it’s one of 14 states that doesn’t cap how long probation sentences can be. (Thirty-two states have limited probation sentences to no more than 5 years.) Further, the Justice Center says that they have anecdotal evidence that probation isn’t being used as an alternative because “a large portion of felonies receive split sentences” that include both prison and probation.

Last month, Rhode Island’s governor created the Justice Reinvestment Working Group in order to get to the bottom of the state’s use of probation. One answer I hope the group will uncover as they develop a path to more reasonable uses of correctional control is exactly why Rhode Island decided to leave its neighbors behind in the use of probation:

Graph showing that since 1989, Rhode Island has had a much higher portion of its population on probation than the other New England states.The rate of probation in Rhode Island is more than twice as high as the rate of probation in most other New England states. (Massachusetts was not included in the graph above because the state changed its reporting methods multiple times during the previous decade. However, in the most current available data, Massachusetts reported a rate of 1,033 adults on probation per 100,000 residents, less than half Rhode Island’s rate of 2,268 per 100,000 residents.)

6 Responses

  1. Breaking Down A Prison Nation: A review of Locked Down, Locked Out | Prison Policy Initiative says, 2 weeks after publication:

    […] between families, prison activists, those incarcerated, and the hundreds of thousands caught in the wider net of correctional control. For example, when speaking about abolition-based action, she describes how successful efforts to […]

  2. Prison industry vendors react to “prison reform” talk | Prison Policy Initiative says, 2 weeks, 6 days after publication:

    […] there are plenty of ways to profit if governments merely transfer their prison addictions to other unnecessary forms of social control. Segal […]

  3. Prison industry vendorz react to “prison reform” talk | Moorbey'z Blog says, 3 weeks, 2 days after publication:

    […] there are plenty of ways to profit if governments merely transfer their prison addictions to other unnecessary forms of social control. Segal […]

  4. States of Women’s Incarceration: The Global Context | My Blog says, 3 months, 1 week after publication:

    […] their low incarceration rates belie the state’s extensive use of probation and other forms of correctional control. […]

  5. Mass Incarceration: The Whole Pie 2015 | From the Trenches World Report says, 4 months after publication:

    […] type of conditional release from prison) and a staggering — and growing — 3.9 million people onprobation (what is typically an alternative sentence). Particularly given the often onerous conditions of […]

  6. Best investigative criminal justice journalism of 2015 | Prison Policy Initiative says, 4 months, 2 weeks after publication:

    […] May Sound Light, but Punishments Can Land Hard by Shaila Dewan The New York Times Probation can sound infinitely better than a jail sentence, but this article describes how too often […]

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comments are moderated and there may be a delay before your comment appears. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Tweet this page Follow @PrisonPolicy on Twitter Get our newsletter Donate Contact Us


Nothing scheduled right now. Invite us to to your city, college or organization.