Exploitation
- Sections
- Reports and campaigns
- Briefings
- Data visualizations
- Contracts database
- Related issues
- Research library
Incarcerated people and their families are literally a captive market that private companies — with the collusion of the facilities — are all too eager to exploit. We are bringing these practices to light and fighting back.
Below is some of our key research and organizing:
Reports and campaigns
Revenues from communication fees, commissary purchases, disciplinary fines, and more flow into “Inmate Welfare Funds” meant to benefit incarcerated populations. However, our analysis reveals that they are used more like slush funds that, in many cases, make society’s most vulnerable people pay for prison operations, staff salaries, benefits, and more.
A technology that, until recently, was new in prisons and jails has exploded in popularity in recent years. Our review found that, despite its potential to keep incarcerated people and their families connected, e-messaging has quickly become just another way for companies to profit at their expense.
Incarcerated people and their families often have to pay $1/minute or more for a phone call. Why? Because prisons and jails profit by granting monopoly telephone contracts to the company that will charge families the most.
We uncover how jails collude with telecom companies to eliminate human contact, by replacing in-person visits with expensive, low-quality video chats. Our research and campaign has achieved a number of important victories.
When prisons fail to provide adequate food and other basics, the commissary — which is often run by a private company — is the only option. We use state data to assess what people are buying at prison commissaries and how much they pay.
Telecom companies are marketing tablets to prisons and jails. Our report evaluates Colorado's "prison tablet" contract, uncovering hidden fees and shoddy services.
Prisons have traditionally given people a cash or check upon release, to repay them for money they received or earned while serving their sentence. Now prisons are increasingly giving people mandatory — and fee-riddled — prepaid cards.
How are consumer rights and protections different for people behind bars? Find out in this deep dive from the Prison Policy Initiative's Stephen Raher. (See also our summary of Stephen's article.)
Briefings
- Proposed Biden junk fees rule provides lots of transparency but little protection for incarcerated people by Mike Wessler, February 12, 2024
We called on the Federal Trade Commission to strengthen its proposed rule to explicitly prohibit some of the most abusive junk fees.
- Incarcerated people must be at the forefront of Biden Administration and Federal Trade Commission efforts to end “junk fees” by Mike Wessler, February 8, 2023
We joined the National Consumer Law Center and 27 other organizations to call on the Federal Trade Commission to crack down on abusive fees incarcerated people and their families are forced to pay.
- Insufficient funds: How prison and jail "release cards" perpetuate the cycle of poverty by Stephen Raher, May 3, 2022
We examined release card companies' fee structures to learn how this industry has evolved, and what government leaders can do to stop its worst practices.
- Show me the money: Tracking the companies that have a lock on sending funds to incarcerated people by Stephen Raher and Tiana Herring, November 9, 2021
We looked at all fifty state departments of corrections to figure out which companies hold the contracts to provide money-transfer services and what the fees are to use these services.
- Blood from a stone: How New York prisons force people to pay for their own incarceration
by Tommaso Bardelli, Zach Gillespie and Thuy Linh Tu, October 27, 2021
A study by members of the New York University Prison Education Program Research Collective gives important first-hand accounts of the damage done when prisons shift financial costs to incarcerated people.
- The Biden Administration must walk back the MailGuard program banning letters from home in federal prisons
by Wanda Bertram, July 29, 2021
The telecom company Smart Communications is trying to sell prisons its "MailGuard" service -- where the company scans incarcerated people's letters from home and gives them printed or digital copies instead.
- More states are signing harmful "free prison tablet" contracts
by Mack Finkel and Wanda Bertram, March 7, 2019
Tablet computers are delivering a captive audience to profit-seeking companies, while enabling prisons to cut essential services like law libraries. We investigate.
- How to spot the hidden costs in a “no-cost” tablet contract
by Wanda Bertram and Peter Wagner, July 24, 2018
There's no such thing as a free lunch — or a free tablet.
- Are private prisons driving mass incarceration? by Peter Wagner, October 7, 2015
How do the campaign contributions of the prison phone industry compare to those of the private prison industry?
- How much do incarcerated people earn in each state? by Wendy Sawyer, April 10, 2017
Prison wages come up again and again in discussions of prison conditions and policies. So we set out to find the most up-to-date information available for each state.
- The multi-million dollar market of sending money to an incarcerated loved one by Stephen Raher, January 18, 2017
Private companies are amassing monopoly contracts, with the potential to rake in as much as $172 million from friends and family sending money to incarcerated loved ones.
- Texas prisons, we've got some questions about your commissary vendors
by Stephen Raher, July 26, 2018
In a follow-up to our commissary report, we look at Texas commissary vendors and discover some surprising findings alongside the usual suspects.
- Paging anti-trust lawyers: Prison commissary giants prepare to merge
by Stephen Raher, July 5, 2016
Two of the biggest players in the prison and jail commissary market are planning to merge: The corporate parent of Trinity Services Group will be acquiring Keefe Group.
- Prison bankers cash in on captive customers by Bernadette Rabuy, September 30, 2014
Center for Public Integrity releases first part of a series on web of prison bankers, private vendors, and corrections agencies profiting off families of the incarcerated.
- Prison profiteers use campaign contributions to buy contracts
by Peter Wagner, November 25, 2015
How do the campaign contributions of the prison phone industry compare to those of the private prison industry?
Exactly how many people are incarcerated in the U.S., and how many are held in private facilities? Get the answers with our report Mass Incarceration: The Whole Pie and other big-picture research.
Exploitation in prisons and jails frequently falls on poor people, who are overrepresented in the justice system. Read about how the criminal justice system effectively punishes people for being poor.
Research Library
Didn't find what you were looking for? We also curate a database of virtually all the empirical criminal justice research available online. See the sections of our Research Library on privatization and the economics of incarceration.